12-04-2015, 10:39 PM
(12-04-2015, 09:48 PM)TheRealJustin Wrote:(12-04-2015, 09:42 PM)Wahyu Wrote:(12-04-2015, 09:34 PM)TheRealJustin Wrote:(12-04-2015, 09:27 PM)Wahyu Wrote:(12-04-2015, 09:00 PM)FrostedFake Wrote: Maybe if the person who gave it to him deleted AM6 from his computer. But if not, then its not like he gave it to him. He basically took lord of the rings, copied it, then gave it to his friend. That is piracy.
And even if he did delete it, if he ran it himself before giving it to his friend, I would still consider that piracy anyways since he got the benfit of the program and then gave it to somebody else.
I think Shannon is very often answer questions like this. But let me explain it in another way.
You want to buy video games from the store, the thing you want is to have the goods and play games whenever you want. Now you want to give the video game to another person. You can still play video games and feel the feelings when you play video games? guess what? no, you can not.
This applies also to the movie you bought. Of course there are differences, but basically the same.
Now when we talk about subliminal audio. The advantage that you get, still exists in your brain. If you want to give subliminal audio to a friend, you must revoke it from your mind completely coupled to undo all the benefits you get because it is the most important core value. Can you? guess what? no, you can not.
So, to give a movie away I need to first erase the movie from my mind and forget I ever saw it?
You can't have your cake and eat it too.
No matter how you try to re-frame it, THIS IS NOT PIRACY. THIS IS NOT ILLEGAL, having the piracy code act on things that aren't illegal is SHADY AS FUC* and I lose a TON of respect.
Tht's a straight up fear based bitch move. That's taking advantage. That's criminal in my eyes.
You only need to give the stuff you bought. So, you can not have the stuff and watch it. possess and use stuff (movies) that you buy is the core benefit you get here, not the memories you have.
But... if you can erase the memory, you are welcome to do so. lol
Technicalities are irrelevant.
If I can legally give someone my movies, I can legally give someone my subs.
Ask a judge.
But I can't legally give someone my copy of Logic Pro X, and let them use it for their own use, for example. But this is just an example, there are some things that if you buy yourself, you can't give to others to use, legally. There are no laws for subs yet though, .