05-22-2010, 05:14 AM
I am now on day 13 of the Healthy Knee program. For background, I am 52 and have been a runner since my 20s. In February I slipped on the ice and sprained my left knee. I did not think it was that bad at first. About 5 days later, I went on a 5 mile run. The knee bothered me but I could run through the discomfort. After that, the knee swelled up and I could hardly walk. Since then I have been on a prescription anti-inflammatory and the doc told me to rest it for 6 weeks to see if it would heal. Six weeks came and went, the knee got better but would swell up if I tried to do anything more strenuous than riding a bike. I tried the Maximum Healing Speed program but did not get any noticeable results from that. Based on my symptoms, I appear to have suffered a tear in my meniscus that was having difficulty in fully healing. Thus it would get better, but once I "tested" it, I would relapse. On each of these cycles it seems to have gotten slightly better, but progress has been at a snail's pace. Exasperated, I asked Shannon to create the Healthy Knees program as a last ditch effort to avoid getting an MRI and possible surgery.
On day 10 of the Healthy Knees program I noticed that my knee felt better. So I did a workout where I rode the bike for 20 minutes (easy on the knee) followed by 15 minutes on the elliptical machine (body weight on knee but no impact). Usually, pushing it like that would have led to a setback and a swollen knee. This time I woke up the next day with no swelling. There was still discomfort in the knee but it was no worse than before the exercise (hence the cycle seems to have broken). I did not want to post results too soon given my experience of feeling like it was healing only to have a set back later. On day 13 (yesterday) I did 20 minutes on the bike followed by 20 minutes on the elliptical. Once again, I awoke this morning with no increase in discomfort in the knee. In fact the knee seems to have much less discomfort in general and sometimes I forget that I hurt it. Another way I test the knee, is to stop taking the anti-inflammatory and see how the knee reacts without it. Usually, I can make it 24 hours before it swells up and forces me to take another pill. The last time, I was able to make it 48 hours and even then, it really didn't swell up too much and I could have gone longer.
It is still too soon to know whether the program will take me all the way to healthy knees, defined by me as being able to run (full weight on knee and impact) pain free again. It is also impossible to know how much of my progress is attributable to the program and how much is natural healing. However, I definitely feel like this program has given my natural healing process a noticeable boost.
I will post again in about 2 weeks and let you know if I am able to build on these gains.
On day 10 of the Healthy Knees program I noticed that my knee felt better. So I did a workout where I rode the bike for 20 minutes (easy on the knee) followed by 15 minutes on the elliptical machine (body weight on knee but no impact). Usually, pushing it like that would have led to a setback and a swollen knee. This time I woke up the next day with no swelling. There was still discomfort in the knee but it was no worse than before the exercise (hence the cycle seems to have broken). I did not want to post results too soon given my experience of feeling like it was healing only to have a set back later. On day 13 (yesterday) I did 20 minutes on the bike followed by 20 minutes on the elliptical. Once again, I awoke this morning with no increase in discomfort in the knee. In fact the knee seems to have much less discomfort in general and sometimes I forget that I hurt it. Another way I test the knee, is to stop taking the anti-inflammatory and see how the knee reacts without it. Usually, I can make it 24 hours before it swells up and forces me to take another pill. The last time, I was able to make it 48 hours and even then, it really didn't swell up too much and I could have gone longer.
It is still too soon to know whether the program will take me all the way to healthy knees, defined by me as being able to run (full weight on knee and impact) pain free again. It is also impossible to know how much of my progress is attributable to the program and how much is natural healing. However, I definitely feel like this program has given my natural healing process a noticeable boost.
I will post again in about 2 weeks and let you know if I am able to build on these gains.